DIY Finch Feeder or Remodel

Simply put, attracting birds to an urban yard requires bribery. Making reformations. After all, humans have paved over land where natural forests, marshes and prairies once grew. Much of the terrain is now unfriendly to birds.

Concrete jungle city dwellers have even less to offer birds than suburban and rural residences with more noise and air pollution and less plants and trees. So, why should birds other than non-native pigeons or house sparrows bother visiting?

Providing a natural habitat is best but that’s not always possible. Some of us can still plant some plants or offer water and food though. Not just any food either: High energy favorite foods like black-oil sunflower seeds and Nyjer seeds are best.

The No/No Bronze Tier Bird Feeder has been such a great success. I first observed it at a park. I also tried the No/No Green and Black Finch Feeder; however, I found the container size a bit small and it spilled seed out of the openings too readily. Also, I once saw a goldfinch get a digit caught in it which required three lift off attempts until it freed itself.

A note about the mesh: I think this smaller metal mesh may prevent birds from sticking their digits inside the holes allowing them to cling with their claws instead.

Other than that singular event, the No/No finch feeder is great but Nyjer seed is expensive (about $2 a pound) so I didn’t want to keep filling up a small feeder daily or have a lot dropping to the ground.

The difference between this feeder and other finch feeders is that the mesh is slightly smaller and the size of this feeder is a bit larger. You can put your own creative touch on it.

This DIY project involves re-purposing a Garden Treasures Metal Tube Bird Feeder purchased for $10.00 at Lowes but you don’t need one to make this feeder. The problem with the Garden Treasures feeder was the presence of open ports which spilled seed. American Goldfinches were clinging to the sides and pulling out seed through its mesh sides more often than perched on at the ports anyway. So I remodeled it. I removed the mesh and installed new, longer, slightly finer mesh and a longer threaded rod. I kept the old feeder’s yellow top and bottom parts. It’s basically the same feeder but longer, narrower and with slightly finer mesh than the No/No finch feeder—the smaller openings slows down consumption and seed falling to the ground. You can create yours totally from scratch though and make it any way you like.

The finches have to work a bit harder but they still think it is worth it. They’re constantly on it as the photos and video show.

Ok so here is the list of items I used to make this DIY finch feeder:

  • Stainless Steel 304 Black Epoxy Coated Mesh #12 .023 Screen 12″x24″
  • Threaded Rod
  • Couplers
  • Washer
  • Nut
  • Metal florist wire (I sewed the mesh together with this taking care to eliminate sharp edges)
  • Top and bottom from Garden Treasures feeder (you can substitute with other items maybe a plastic dish or unused oil funnel on top, for example)

A perch-less feeder is great for American Goldfinches as they are adept at clinging. Sometimes House finches will cling to it but more often eat seeds at the bottom and they still generally prefer the sunflower No/No feeder. This is pretty much an American Goldfinch feeder. Also I’m very surprised and happy to report that House Sparrows have zero interest in this feeder so far.

Sorry, I don’t have photos of the process of making it. Hopefully these images are self-explanatory. I didn’t have a camera handy at the time but here are a few snapshots of it and a video of it in action too. The bottom is a little crooked but I’ll try evening it out when it comes time to clean it.

Old Garden Treasures feeder with open ports


hg     gh


Remodeled feeder in action

American Goldfinches on the feeder



I’m shocked at the amount of American goldfinch visitors we are getting with this feeder filled with Nyjer seed. It is nonstop action and it’s nice to know we are helping these native birds.

One last word of caution about squirrels. They WILL try to chew through this feeder so your best best is to place it on a pole with a squirrel baffle below it. An 18-inch Woodlink Audubon Wrap Around Squirrel Baffle placed about 5 foot above ground works great. Here are the two feeders now protected by it here:


DIY feeder and No/No sunflower feeder

The Lonicera sempervirens in the background is already getting ready to bloom. Happy sixth day of Spring.

1 Comment

Posted by on March 26, 2016 in Uncategorized


Garden update

In addition to designing, planting, and other garden activities, simply looking at a garden is an enjoyment. If you can recall the history of a particular plant, how it has grown and changed, that can add to the enjoyment. fhThe photo above was taken a few weeks ago. Sadly, my last hummingbird sighting was many days earlier. The Ipomoea sloteri (cardinal climber) in the distance was at its peak right before a couple of light frosts put an end to all its flowers. The sound of traffic can still be heard while nestled in this hammock but moments like these remain a mini-paradise to me. Having been born and raised in a very urban Bronx home without a yard helps me appreciate and cherish moments like this.

Here are a few more photos I took before the frost came. The Canna lilies (Canna spp.) and Tithonia rotundifolia (Mexican sunflowers) suffered most; however, a few Lonicera sempervirens (native honeysuckle) vines are still blooming lightly, the Ipomoea lobata is unfazed as are many salvias and the thicker-leaved Agastaches are still flowering well.IMG_0069IMG_0035IMG_0078

Marigolds. They’re the easiest flowering plant to grow from seed, they bloom nonstop, resist frost and attract bees. Although I’ve seen many bumble bees on these flower cultivars, I plan to replace them with something even more wildlife-friendly next season.


The grass is a bit unruly here but the hummingbird didn’t seem to mind.


Below is Salvia coccinea grown from seed, frost-bitten but still flowering with Ilex verticillata ‘Winter Red’ berries reddening in the background. If you can find the native species instead of cultivars, that is ideal since they’re typically hardier and you’re guaranteed to attract and support wildlife since plant species have coevolved over millions of years with specific wildlife.



IMG_0029 IMG_0025

    IMG_0038   IMG_0034      IMG_0021


This is probably the last time I saw a hummingbird. Sipping from the hot air balloon feeder and then perched on a young Albizia julibrissin commonly known as Mimosa tree.

3Hopefully this hummingbird has migrated safely to a warmer zone.


Leave a comment

Posted by on November 1, 2015 in Uncategorized


Female Northern Cardinal checks out hummingbird feeders


Leave a comment

Posted by on August 26, 2015 in Uncategorized